11th Grade English & Writing

Peer Review Protocol

Restate the reasoning, mark the evidence, and name one revision.

Protocol Pairs or small groups Updated

Use this for a literary paragraph, a full essay, or a section of an AP Seminar report. The writer leaves with a revision plan, not a cloud of reactions.

Norms

  • Talk about the writing, not the person.
  • Be specific. “Confusing” needs a sentence attached to it.
  • Do not rewrite the draft in the author’s voice.
  • The writer owns the decision about what to change.

The round (about 15 minutes)

1. Silent read, 4 minutes. The reviewer reads the whole piece once without a pen, then again with one. No comments yet.

2. Say-back, 2 minutes. The reviewer states the line of reasoning in two or three sentences: “You seem to be arguing that…, because…, and then….” The writer may say only “yes,” “not quite,” or correct a factual miss. No defending.

3. Written notes, 4 minutes. The reviewer answers only these prompts:

  • One place the evidence is actually doing work:
  • One place commentary is missing, thin, or talking about something else:
  • One question I still have:

4. Conversation, 3 minutes. The reviewer reads the notes. The writer asks one clarifying question.

5. Revision plan, 2 minutes. The writer writes a single next move: the paragraph they will rebuild, the claim they will narrow, or the source they will reread. The plan is a sentence, not a promise to “add more detail.”

If you are the writer

If the say-back is not the argument you thought you wrote, believe the say-back long enough to check. Readers report the argument that made it to the page.

If you are the reviewer

You are not the teacher and you are not a copy editor. Grammar comments wait until the line of reasoning is visible. A clean sentence that argues the wrong thing is not the priority.


Akai Milson · akaimilson.com · Classroom use with attribution. College Board’s current materials govern AP Seminar tasks and scoring.